home / san mateo / the highlands

san mateo neighborhood guide · property nerds® at compass

The Highlands, San Mateo Homes for sale, recent sales and a Property Nerd’s guide

An unincorporated Eichler neighborhood on the ridge above Crystal Springs Reservoir: about 800 homes, roughly 650 of them built by Eichler Homes from 1955 on, with San Mateo addresses and county rules.

drawing the outline…
builtEichler Homes started here in 1955 (X-100 National Register nomination); Census estimates put the tract's median home at 1959, with about 54 percent of units from the 1950s and 29 percent from the 1960s
homesAbout 800 homes (community association; county parcel maps show about 810 parcels), about 650 of them built by Eichler Homes (National Register nomination)
zip94402
school districtsSan Mateo-Foster City School District (TK-8); San Mateo Union High School District
outlineThe Highlands (approximate outline traced from the boundary streets)
datalive from the MLS

The Highlands by the numbers

the highlands by the numbers · live from the mls

  • for sale now… 
  • median list price… 
  • homes sold, last 12 months… 
  • median sale price, 12 mo… 
  • median price per sq ft, sold… 
  • sale price vs. list… 

Calculated in your browser from MLS data for The Highlands (approximate outline traced from the boundary streets). Sales are single-family homes, townhomes and condos.

homes in the highlands · live from the mls

Homes for sale, for rent and recently sold in The Highlands

Every active listing, rental and closed sale in The Highlands from the MLS, updated automatically, with a map of the neighborhood outline.

Get alerts for new The Highlands listings: open this neighborhood in our full search and tap Save Search.

Loading listings…

Listings come from MLSListings and other MLSs through IDX and show their listing brokerage; confirm details with the listing agent. The map outline is the neighborhood boundary used by our listing search (The Highlands (approximate outline traced from the boundary streets)); it may not match every local definition.

the story

How The Highlands came to be

The Highlands began with a marketing problem. When Eichler Homes started building on this ridge in 1955, neither Interstate 280 nor Highway 92 existed, and the X-100's National Register nomination describes the site as remote and hard to reach. The answer was a show house: the X-100, an experimental steel-framed home designed by the California firm Jones & Emmons. It opened on October 6, 1956, stayed open for three months and drew what was reported as 150,000 visitors, according to the nomination. It still stands on Lexington Avenue, backing onto watershed land, and was listed in the National Register of Historic Places in June 2016. It is a private home, no public access.

Around it grew a neighborhood of about 800 homes, by the San Mateo Highlands Community Association's count, roughly 650 of them built by Eichler Homes, per the nomination. The association dates its Eichlers to the 1950s and 1960s and notes other mid-century designs among them, and Census estimates for the Highlands tract agree: a median year built of 1959, with about 54 percent of units from the 1950s and 29 percent from the 1960s.

Local institutions here grew up outside any city hall. The community association dates to 1956 and still publishes its Lowdown newsletter and runs a Fourth of July celebration. The Highlands Recreation District, a separate public district formed on September 24, 1957 (county LAFCo records), runs the pool, courts and recreation center on Lexington Avenue. Sewer service comes from the Crystal Springs County Sanitation District, a county district formed in 1947. The whole area is still unincorporated San Mateo County, even though every address says San Mateo.

streets and homes

The streets and the houses

The streets follow the ridge. Lexington Avenue runs along the western crest above the watershed and is the longest street in county parcel records, with about 140 lots; Bunker Hill Drive loops through the middle, and Ticonderoga Drive climbs in from Polhemus Road at the south end. Many names come from the Revolutionary War: Lexington, Bunker Hill, Ticonderoga, Bennington, Oriskany, Brandywine, Trenton, White Plains, Cowpens and Yorktown. Short places branch off the south end (Sheraton, Powhatan, Turtle Bay, French Creek, Stoney Point), and Laurel Hill Drive, Tarrytown Street, Seneca Lane, Roxbury Lane and Forge Road fill the north end near Crystal Springs Road.

An original Highlands Eichler is a post-and-beam house with floor-to-ceiling glass and an open plan, as the community association describes them. Like Eichlers in general, they sit on concrete slab foundations with radiant heating pipes in the slab and no attic, as the X-100 nomination puts it. The hillside adds a twist: a mid-century modern magazine notes original two-story Eichlers built on lots too small for the single-story plan, and many later second-story additions that do not always match the originals. Lots run about 7,900 to 10,400 square feet for the middle half, by our measurement of county parcel maps, and nearly all are zoned R-1/S-8, the county's single-family district.

Jurisdiction is simple inside the Census-defined Highlands: 801 of its 807 parcels are flagged unincorporated in county parcel records, and the other six carry no flag. The lines get finer at the southeast corner, where the attached homes at the south end of Ticonderoga Drive and the houses on Lakewood Circle are inside the City of San Mateo; they are covered in our Baywood Park & College Heights guide. Near Polhemus Road, check the parcel record before you assume which rules apply.

streets in the highlands

  • Lexington Avenue
  • Bunker Hill Drive
  • Ticonderoga Drive
  • Laurel Hill Drive
  • Laurel Hill Court
  • Tarrytown Street
  • Yorktown Road
  • Monticello Road
  • Brandywine Road
  • Forge Road
  • New Brunswick Drive
  • Allegheny Way
  • Cobblehill Place
  • Bennington Drive
  • Oriskany Drive
  • Trenton Place
  • Seneca Lane
  • Roxbury Lane
  • Newport Street
  • Hoods Point Way
  • Sheraton Place
  • Lundys Lane
  • Stoney Point Place
  • French Creek Place
  • White Plains Court
  • Polhemus Road
  • Crystal Springs Road

parks and places

Parks, shops and landmarks near The Highlands

  • park

    Highlands Recreation District center

    The district's center at 1851 Lexington Avenue has a pool, tennis and pickleball courts, a gym, a fitness room, a playground and a multipurpose room, plus an early education center and after-school programs (district website). State protected-areas data map the site at about 3.7 acres, open access.

  • shopping

    Crystal Springs shopping center

    A small center at Polhemus Road and De Anza Boulevard, about half a mile straight-line from the recreation center, with a supermarket, a bakery and a produce market (public maps). It sits just inside the city limit.

  • trail

    Crystal Springs Regional Trail

    County parks run the paved Sawyer Camp segment, about 6 miles from Crystal Springs Road north to Hillcrest Boulevard, with a lot off Crystal Springs Road about 1.2 miles straight-line west of the recreation center and the 600-plus-year-old Jepson Laurel midway. The Crystal Springs segment starts at Highway 92 and is open to hikers, joggers and equestrians but not bicycles.

  • landmark

    College of San Mateo

    The public community college's 153-acre campus on the next hill east opened in 1963 and includes a planetarium (college history page), about 1.1 miles straight-line.

schools and commute

School districts and getting around

School districts

The Highlands is in the San Mateo-Foster City School District for TK-8 and the San Mateo Union High School District; Census school-district maps put every parcel in the neighborhood in those two districts. Highlands Elementary School, a San Mateo-Foster City district school, is on Newport Street in the middle of the neighborhood. Attendance boundaries change, so check the exact address with each district.

San Mateo Union High guide · Silicon Valley school districts

Getting around

  • Highway 92 and Interstate 280 meet at the south edge; the interchange is about 1 mile straight-line from the recreation center.
  • Hillsdale Caltrain (50 East 28th Avenue, Zone 2) is about 2.9 miles straight-line; San Mateo station is about 3.5 miles and Belmont about 3.8 miles.
  • SamTrans school-day routes 56 and 58 end at Polhemus Road and Paul Scannell Drive, and Route 250 and the weekday CSM route link the College of San Mateo with downtown San Mateo.
  • Crystal Springs Road runs northeast toward Hillsborough and downtown San Mateo; Polhemus Road runs southeast to De Anza Boulevard and Highway 92.
  • The Sawyer Camp segment's parking off Crystal Springs Road is about 1.2 miles straight-line west, across Interstate 280.

nerd notes

Buying or selling in The Highlands: what we check

Buying here

  • Unincorporated means county: building permits and planning go through San Mateo County, the county maintains the roads, sewer is the Crystal Springs County Sanitation District (run by county Public Works), and county maps show water from California Water Service. Read the tax bill for the small districts county LAFCo lists here, including County Service Area No. 1 and drainage, lighting and landscape maintenance districts.
  • Original Eichlers were heated by pipes in the concrete slab and have no attic (X-100 nomination). Ask whether the radiant system is original, repaired or replaced, and what heats the house today; a slab leak is a different repair than a furnace.
  • Fire zones vary by street. CAL FIRE's 2023 state map puts about 120 parcels along the watershed edge in a State Responsibility Area Moderate zone, and its 2025 local map shows Moderate on many other blocks and High on about 20 parcels. Read the natural hazard disclosure for the exact lot.
  • State seismic hazard maps (San Mateo quadrangle, 2018) show earthquake-induced landslide zones under roughly 60 lots, including parts of Yorktown Road, Laurel Hill Drive, Bunker Hill Drive and Oriskany Drive; ask for geotechnical reports before planning a second story. FEMA maps the whole neighborhood as Zone X (minimal flood hazard).
  • A 2018 magazine profile noted the Highlands has never had an architectural review process. Check the county's current R-1/S-8 standards and its ADU and SB 9 rules before you plan an addition, and expect county, not city, review.

Selling here

  • Pull the county permit history before listing, especially for second stories, room additions and garage or carport conversions; county records are the ones that matter here.
  • If the house is an original two-story Eichler model, say so and show the original plan.
  • Order the natural hazard disclosure early; fire zone class and landslide zones differ from lot to lot.
  • List the county services (sewer district, water provider, recreation district) in the disclosure package so buyers can read the tax bill without surprises.

nerd noteCommissions are always negotiable, and we offer bundled services, so ask us what's included.

faq

The Highlands questions, answered

Is the San Mateo Highlands in the City of San Mateo?

No. It is unincorporated San Mateo County with San Mateo 94402 mailing addresses, so planning, permits and roads are county matters and sewer comes from the county-run Crystal Springs County Sanitation District. A few blocks at the southeast corner, such as the south end of Ticonderoga Drive and Lakewood Circle, are inside the city; check the parcel record.

How many Eichlers are in the Highlands?

About 650, built by Eichler Homes starting in 1955, according to the X-100's National Register nomination. The community association counts about 800 homes in all, so other mid-century designs and later rebuilds fill in the rest.

What is the X-100?

An experimental steel-framed show house Eichler Homes built in 1956 to designs by Jones & Emmons, listed in the National Register of Historic Places in June 2016. It is a private home on Lexington Avenue with no public access.

Which school districts serve the Highlands?

San Mateo-Foster City School District (TK-8) and San Mateo Union High School District. Highlands Elementary School is on Newport Street inside the neighborhood. Boundaries change, so check the exact address with the districts.

Is the Highlands in a flood or fire zone?

FEMA maps it as Zone X, minimal flood hazard. Fire zones matter more: CAL FIRE maps show Moderate zones along the watershed edge and through much of the neighborhood, and High on about 20 parcels. The natural hazard disclosure answers it for a specific lot.

talk to a property nerd

Thinking about The Highlands? Let's run your numbers.

Eric, Janelle and the Boyenga Team have sold more than 2,520 Silicon Valley homes, $2.6+ billion in all, since 1996. Get a value, a plan, or a straight answer about a street.

on the home styles field guide

Home styles in The Highlands

The Highlands shows up on these plates in our home styles field guide. Each plate shows how to spot the style from the sidewalk, with live listings opened to San Mateo.

See all nine plates in the home styles field guide

live market · san mateo

San Mateo right now

City-wide numbers read from the MLS each time this page loads. A neighborhood can trade differently from its city, so ask us for the sales on your street.

  • homes for sale…houses, condos, townhomes
  • new this week…by days on market
  • median list price…of homes for sale
  • median days on market…of homes for sale
  • 12 months of sales…median sale price

Full San Mateo dashboard in Market Pulse →Offer Lab for San MateoSan Mateo neighborhoods rankedWhat’s my home worth?Get early access

Listing data comes from the MLS through our IDX feeds and is shown as reported; it isn’t guaranteed. Repeat listings from overlapping feeds are removed, and land and mobile homes are left out.

Questions about The Highlands? Send us a note.

Eric & Janelle Boyenga

Eric & Janelle Boyenga

Founders DRE01254725 / 01254724

Founders DRE01254725 / 01254724

Name*

Name

Phone*

Phone

Message